If you’ve been looking into ways to make money through reselling, chances are you’ve heard of online arbitrage vs retail arbitrage. They’re both popular methods that allow you to buy products at a low price and sell them for a profit, usually through platforms like Amazon or eBay.
But what’s the difference between these two options? How can you decide which one is the better fit? In this guide, we’ll break down the differences, pros, and cons of online arbitrage vs retail arbitrage so that you can make an informed decision.
What Is Arbitrage?
Before we get into the comparison, let’s clarify what arbitrage means. Arbitrage is buying an item from one market and selling it in another for profit. It’s all about finding those hidden deals that others might overlook and flipping them for more than you paid.
Online and retail arbitrage follow this principle, but how you find and source products differs significantly.
Let’s take a closer look at both.
What Is Online Arbitrage?
Online arbitrage involves purchasing products from online retailers like Walmart, Target, or other websites at a lower price and then reselling them on platforms like Amazon or eBay for a higher price. In the battle of online arbitrage vs retail arbitrage, this method is often seen as more convenient because everything is done from your computer or phone.
Instead of going to stores to hunt for deals, you do all this from the comfort of your computer or phone.
How Does Online Arbitrage Work?
Here are some steps:
Find Products: You browse various online stores for discounted or clearance items.
Analyze Profitability: You check if you can sell that product for a higher price on a marketplace like Amazon or eBay, factoring in shipping, fees, and other costs.
Purchase and Ship: Once you find a profitable item, you buy it and have it shipped either to your house or directly to Amazon’s warehouses if you use Amazon FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon).
Resell and Profit: Finally, you list the product for sale, and when someone buys it, you ship it (or Amazon ships it for you if you use FBA), and you pocket the profit.
What Is Retail Arbitrage?
On the other hand, retail arbitrage involves physically going to brick-and-mortar stores like Walmart, Target, or TJ Maxx and hunting for items on clearance or heavily discounted. The goal is the same: buy low, sell high. When comparing online arbitrage vs retail arbitrage, this method is often more time-consuming but can offer unique findings that aren’t available online.
How Does Retail Arbitrage Work?
Here are some steps:
Go to Stores: You visit retail stores and scour the clearance sections for discounted items.
Analyze Profit Margins: Like in online arbitrage, you check if you can resell the item for more than you paid, considering fees and other costs.
Purchase and Resell: Once you’ve bought your items, you can either list them for sale on Amazon, eBay, or another online marketplace or keep them until they’re more in demand.
Fulfillment: After selling, you pack and ship the items yourself (or, again, use FBA).
Online Arbitrage vs Retail Arbitrage: Key Differences
One of the main differences between online arbitrage vs retail arbitrage is how you source products. Online arbitrage allows you to shop from the comfort of your home, while retail arbitrage involves physically going to stores. Both have their advantages and disadvantages.
Pros and Cons of Online Arbitrage
Pros of Online Arbitrage
Convenience: You can shop from anywhere, any time—no need to leave your house.
Access to More Stores: Your “store” options are endless since you’re shopping online. You can browse hundreds of websites from different locations in minutes.
No Physical Hunting: Online tools can help you scan prices, check profitability, and make faster decisions, which saves time compared to driving around to stores.
Price Comparisons: It’s easier to compare prices across online stores without being physically there. This helps you spot deals quickly.
Cons of Online Arbitrage
More Competition: Because online arbitrage is so accessible, it’s very competitive. You may find that many sellers are already trying to resell the same products you see.
Shipping Delays: Since you’re ordering online, there’s always the chance of shipping delays, which can slow down your ability to resell items.
Price Fluctuations: Online prices change frequently, so a deal you find today might not be available tomorrow.
Pros and Cons of Retail Arbitrage
Pros of Retail Arbitrage
Less Competition: Fewer people are willing to go to stores to hunt for deals physically so you may face less competition than with online arbitrage.
Immediate Inventory: When buying products in a store, you have them in hand immediately. There is no waiting for shipping, so you can list them and sell them immediately.
Unique Finds: Some stores have clearance or markdowns that aren’t available online, giving you access to exceptional deals.
Cons of Retail Arbitrage
Time-Consuming: You must physically go to multiple stores to find deals, which can take time and effort.
Limited Inventory: You’re limited by what’s in stock at the stores you visit. Once it’s gone, it’s gone.
Geographical Constraints: Your options are limited if you live in an area with fewer retail stores or less inventory.
Which Is More Profitable: Online Arbitrage vs Retail Arbitrage?
Regarding profitability in online arbitrage vs retail arbitrage, both methods can be highly profitable depending on how much time you dedicate and how well you research your products.
Online Arbitrage Profitability
Online arbitrage is often more scalable because you can browse multiple stores quickly. However, it can be more competitive, affecting your profit margins. Many online sellers also use advanced software to scan for deals so that you may compete with people using automation tools.
Retail Arbitrage Profitability
While more time-intensive, retail arbitrage can offer higher profit margins, especially if you find unique or heavily discounted items that others don’t have access to. Because fewer people are willing to go store-hopping, there’s a chance you can uncover deals that the masses haven’t discovered.
Which One Is Easier for Beginners?
If you’re just getting started, online arbitrage vs retail arbitrage presents different challenges. Online arbitrage may be more accessible because you don’t need to travel from store to store. You can get started with nothing more than a computer and some essential research tools.
On the other hand, retail arbitrage might be more rewarding for those who enjoy shopping and don’t mind the physical effort of going to multiple stores. Plus, there’s something satisfying about physically finding a hidden gem on a clearance shelf.
Tools to Help With Both Online and Retail Arbitrage
Whether you choose online arbitrage vs retail arbitrage, several tools can help you make the most of your efforts:
Price Checking Tools: Tools like Keepa or CamelCamelCamel for Amazon can help you track price history and decide whether an item is a good deal.
Amazon Seller App: If you’re doing retail arbitrage, the Amazon Seller App lets you scan barcodes in-store to check current prices and fees on Amazon, so you know immediately if an item is profitable.
Cashback Websites: If you’re doing online arbitrage, cashback websites like Rakuten can help you save even more money on your purchases.
Fulfillment Options in Online Arbitrage vs Retail Arbitrage
No matter which arbitrage method you choose, you’ll need to think about how you want to handle fulfillment:
Amazon FBA: Many sellers use Amazon’s FBA service, which means Amazon stores, packs, and ships their items for them. This can be a huge time-saver, but it comes with extra fees.
Self-Fulfillment: If you want to save money, you can handle the packing and shipping yourself. This might be more practical if you start or have a smaller inventory.
Conclusion
So, after comparing online arbitrage vs retail arbitrage, which should you choose? Ultimately, it comes down to your preferences and what you can afford. Online arbitrage is a great option if you’re looking for convenience and scalability. However, if you enjoy the thrill of the hunt and don’t mind spending time in stores, retail arbitrage can be just as profitable, if not more.
So, why not try both and see which works better for you? Whether you choose online arbitrage or retail arbitrage, both can be profitable if you’re willing to put in the effort.
Need a little help with online arbitrage? Reach out to Ecomsole. They make it easy to get started and grow your business. Book a meeting and see how they can support you every step of the way.
FAQs
